The Forever War by Joe Haldeman, as chosen by Mike.

Tim: B. Thematically and metaphorically, it did a lot.

Liza: B+ I don't normally read science fiction, but I really enjoyed style of writing.

Katie: B. I don't like science fiction, but it was an ok story and I liked the character.

Mike: A. Because I think the rest of you didn't understand it.

Catherine: B. I really did like it -- and it was a great book club choice.

Karen: C+ I liked it a lot more after Mike's explanation of the whole Vietnam war metaphor.